Change Implementation Techniques for Laying a Foundation for New Ways

Technique 1.24 Assumptions to Help Determine Different Cultures or Sub‐cultures

{product-noshow 8|name|cart|picture|link|border|menuid:206|pricedis3|pricetax1}

Introduction

The answers to the following questions (circle the most appropriate answer) can help to indicate what type of organisation you are and/or dealing with

Type 1

. Does your organisation believe that the actions of the organisation are ultimately the action of its staff?

Yes Maybe No

. Does the success of the organisation depend upon staff's knowledge, skill and commitment?

Yes Maybe No

. Are the knowledge and skills required found locally and based on the organisation's core technology?

Yes Maybe No

. No matter how carefully engineered the production process is or how carefully rules and routines are specified, will staff have to deal with unpredictable contingencies?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff members have the capacity to learn and to deal with surprises, such as unpredictable contingencies?

Yes Maybe No

. As most operations are interdependent, can staff operate in collaborative teams in which openness and mutual trust are highly valued?

Yes Maybe No

Type 2

. Do staff work under the notion that nature can and should be mastered, ie that which is possible should be done?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff believe that operations should be based on science and available technology?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff enjoy solving puzzles and overcoming problems?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff believe that products and outcomes should be useful and be improvements?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff believe that solutions should be orientated towards elegance, simplicity and precision, ie keep it neat and simple?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff believe that the ideal world is one of elegant machines and processes working in perfect precision and harmony without human intervention?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff believe people are the problem ‐ they make mistakes and hence should be designed out of the system wherever possible?

Yes Maybe No

Type 3

. Do staff believe that without financial survival and growth, there are no returns to shareholders or to society?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff believe that the economic environment is perpetually competitive and potentially hostile, ie in a war where one cannot trust anyone?

Yes Maybe No

. Do staff believe that the most senior manager should be a "lone hero" (isolated and alone, yet appearing to be omniscient and in total control, and feeling indispensable, ie I'm okay; after all, I'm here; they are not okay; they have not made it to the top)?

Yes Maybe No

. Is your organisation one where staff are more likely to provide information reinforcing senior management's view rather than supplying reliable data; therefore, senior management members tend to trust their own judgments more and more, due to the absence of a creditable feedback increasing the sense of one's own rightness and omniscience?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that management and organisations are intrinsically hierarchical; with hierarchy measuring status and being the primary means of maintaining control?

Yes Maybe No

. As the organisation grows, does it become more depersonalised and abstract as it is run by rules, routines (systems) and rituals (machine bureaucracy)?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that people are a necessary evil, not an intrinsic value; people are a resource like other resources, to be acquired and managed, not an end in themselves?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that a well‐oiled, machine‐like organisation does not need whole people, only the activities that they are contracted for?

Yes Maybe No

Type 4

. Does your organisation believe that information can be packaged into bits and transmitted electronically?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that more information is better than less?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that the more quantifiable information is the better?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that the paperless office is a possibility and desirable?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that technology leads and people should adapt?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that staff should learn the language and methods of IT?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that management will give up hierarchy if IT provides better coordination mechanisms than the present system?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that the more fully IT‐connected and organisation is, the better it will be?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that people will use information responsibly and appropriately?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that paper will be replaced by electronically‐stored information?

Yes Maybe No

Type 5

. Does your organisation believe that information relevant to operations must include face‐to‐face human contact in order to be accurately understood?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that information may be extracted from raw data and will be meaningful only in a particular context that is itself self‐perpetually changing?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that meaning derives only from complex patterns?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that costs associated with speed may not be worth it?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that too much IT‐connectivity produces information overload?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that the more information you have, the more you need?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that certain kinds of information, such as personal feedback performance appraisal, should not be quantitative and should not be computerised?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that paper is intrinsic to many kinds of tasks?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that technology should be adapted to people and be user‐friendly?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that hierarchy is intrinsic to human systems & a necessary coordination mechanism, no matter how efficient networked communications are?

Yes Maybe No

. Does your organisation believe that the control of information is a necessary management technique and the only way of maintaining power and status?

Yes Maybe No

Comments

. The number of answers

Type

Yes

Maybe

No

1




2




3




4




5




. If "yes" answers predominate within a particular category, the more likely the culture represents

Type 1 (operator type of culture)

Type 2 (engineering type of culture)

Type 3 (executive type of culture)

Type 4 (IT dominant culture)

Type 5 (less IT dominant culture) (source: Edgar Schein, 2004)


Free
5 5 1 Product

1 Month

Start your Change Management Plan today

With our FREE Basic membership


FREE fast start guides to review your organizations

FREE access to change management knowledge base

FREE change management case review

 

JOIN NOW


Become a Member - the benefits:

  • Ability to download a hardcopy(s) of the entire 5 x volume knowledgebase
  • Copy, paste and print content of interest
  • Be personally notified about regular content updates
  • Receive advance copies of the newsletters (including interesting articles)
  • Receive notification of upcoming events like Change Management Masterclasses

designed by: bluetinweb

Free 1:1 Consultation

get a free 1:1 consultation to apply
the relevant concepts to your specific
change management project